TL;DR — Quick Summary
Brooklyn truck accident injuries have to clear New York’s serious injury threshold before you can recover pain and suffering. The 2026 reform deleted the 90/180-day category, leaving eight ways to qualify — and every one of them now demands permanent or objectively verifiable harm. The practical good news for truck victims is that the force involved means these cases usually clear the threshold on a fracture or significant disfigurement without difficulty. The less obvious changes matter more: juries now decide fault before injury, and a plaintiff found mostly at fault recovers no non-economic damages at all.
New York is a no-fault state, which sounds protective and works out to be a filter. Your own insurer pays your initial medical bills and a portion of lost earnings regardless of who caused the crash. What it will not pay is anything for what the injury actually did to your life.
To get that, you have to step outside the no-fault system entirely — and the gate you step through is the serious injury threshold. In 2026 that gate got narrower.
What No-Fault Covers Before Any of This Matters
Basic no-fault benefits in New York provide up to $50,000 per person for necessary medical expenses, a percentage of lost earnings subject to a monthly cap, and limited other reasonable expenses. It applies regardless of fault, which is genuinely useful in the weeks after a crash.
It also has a deadline people miss constantly: the no-fault application must generally be submitted within 30 days of the accident. Missing it can jeopardize coverage for treatment you have already received. Against a commercial truck, $50,000 tends to disappear inside the first hospitalization, which is exactly why the threshold question arrives so quickly in these cases.
The Eight Categories That Remain
Under Insurance Law § 5102(d), a serious injury is now one that results in:
- Death
- Dismemberment
- Significant disfigurement
- A fracture
- Loss of a fetus
- Permanent loss of use of a body organ, member, function or system
- Permanent consequential limitation of use of a body organ or member
- Significant limitation of use of a body function or system
What is gone is the ninth: the 90/180-day category, which allowed a claim where a medically determined non-permanent injury prevented someone from performing substantially all of their usual daily activities for at least 90 of the 180 days following the crash. Part EE of Chapter 58 of the Laws of 2026 removed it for actions commenced on or after May 26, 2026.
That effective date works on the filing date, not the crash date. An accident from 2024 that is filed today falls under the amended definition. This catches people who assumed the law that applied when they were injured is the law that will govern their case.

Why Brooklyn Truck Accident Injuries Usually Clear the Threshold
This is the part worth holding onto if you have been reading alarming coverage of the reform. The elimination of the 90/180 category is a serious problem for minor and moderate collisions. It is much less of a problem for truck cases.
A loaded commercial vehicle can weigh twenty times what a passenger car weighs, and that ratio produces injuries that land squarely inside the remaining categories:
- Fractures — a category all on its own, requiring no permanency analysis, and common in almost any significant truck impact
- Crush injuries and amputations, reaching dismemberment and permanent loss of use
- Scarring from lacerations, burns, and surgery, supporting significant disfigurement
- Spinal cord injury and traumatic brain injury with imaging and neurological findings
- Internal organ damage requiring surgical intervention
A documented fracture ends the threshold argument. That is a meaningfully different position from the rear-end and sideswipe cases that the 2026 reform was aimed at, and it is one reason truck claims resolve at levels ordinary collisions do not — our breakdown of truck accident settlements in New York covers realistic ranges.
Where the Reform Genuinely Hurts
Not every truck collision produces a fracture, and the harder cases are now considerably harder.
The injuries most exposed by the loss of the 90/180 category are the ones that are real but resist imaging: soft tissue and whiplash injuries, herniated and bulging discs where the defense argues degeneration rather than trauma, chronic pain syndromes, and — most troublingly — mild traumatic brain injury that presents with genuine cognitive and behavioral symptoms but a clean scan.
A concussion from a low-speed delivery van collision that leaves someone unable to work for four months no longer has the 90/180 route available. It has to qualify as a permanent consequential limitation or a significant limitation of use, and that means objective evidence: neuropsychological testing, range-of-motion measurement, specialist findings, and a treatment record that is consistent from the beginning.
The practical instruction that follows is unglamorous but decisive. Report every symptom at the first medical visit, including the ones that seem minor. Attend every appointment. Gaps in treatment are the single most effective argument the defense has, and they are entirely avoidable.
Fault Now Comes First — Literally
The reform changed more than the injury definition, and this second change has received far less attention than it deserves.
Insurance Law § 5104(a) now sequences motor vehicle trials: liability is decided first, serious injury second, damages third. Previously these questions could be presented together, which let a jury weigh the severity of what happened to a person alongside the question of who caused it.
Separating them is a defense advantage. A jury allocating fault before hearing the full injury evidence is a jury deciding percentages in the abstract. Combined with the amendment to CPLR § 1411 — under which a plaintiff found mostly at fault in a motor vehicle case is barred from recovering non-economic damages entirely — the fault phase has become the phase that decides the case.
For truck victims this raises the value of early evidence enormously. Carrier investigators reach crash scenes fast and shape the fault record before anyone contests it, and identifying every responsible party is now as much about defending your fault percentage as about reaching more insurance. Our guide to who is liable in a Brooklyn truck accident walks through the full chain.
The New $100,000 Cap, and Who It Applies To
The 2026 package also created a narrow cap on non-economic damages, and it is frequently described more broadly than it actually is.
It limits non-economic damages to $100,000 for an injured person who was at fault and who, at the time of the crash, fell into one of a small set of categories — driving uninsured while responsible for insuring the vehicle, driving while impaired and later convicted, or driving while committing a felony and later convicted. It does not apply to death cases.
For the overwhelming majority of people struck by a truck in Brooklyn, this cap is irrelevant. It is worth knowing about mainly so that an insurer cannot invoke it where it does not apply. Where a fatality is involved, an entirely separate set of rules governs what a family can recover — covered in our guide to a Brooklyn truck accident wrongful death claim.
Pedestrians and Cyclists in Brooklyn
Brooklyn’s streets put a great many people outside vehicles directly alongside commercial traffic — bike lanes running beside truck routes, crosswalks at intersections where trailers make wide turns, and delivery vans working residential blocks all day.
The threshold applies to pedestrians and cyclists the same way it applies to drivers, and the injury patterns tend to clear it: fractures, degloving injuries, and permanent scarring are common in these collisions. The harder problem is the fault phase. Defense arguments in pedestrian and cyclist cases lean on where the person was standing, whether they were in the crosswalk, and whether they were visible — precisely the allocation now decided first and in isolation. The dynamics differ from an ordinary Brooklyn car accident mainly in how much more aggressively the commercial defense is resourced.
Before responding to any offer, it is worth working through what your claim is realistically worth with our free personal injury settlement calculator.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the serious injury threshold in New York?
It is the standard under Insurance Law § 5102(d) that a motor vehicle accident victim must meet to sue for pain and suffering rather than being limited to no-fault benefits. Following the 2026 reform there are eight qualifying categories, all of which require permanent or objectively verifiable harm.
Does a broken bone automatically qualify?
A fracture is its own listed category, so a documented fracture satisfies the threshold without needing to prove permanency or limitation. This is why the reform affects truck cases less than ordinary collisions — the forces involved produce fractures routinely. The threshold is a gateway, though, not a measure of value.
What happened to the 90/180-day rule?
It was eliminated. The category previously allowed a claim where a non-permanent injury prevented someone from performing substantially all of their usual activities for at least 90 of the 180 days after a crash. It no longer exists for actions commenced on or after May 26, 2026, which affects claimants with temporarily disabling injuries most severely.
My accident happened before the law changed. Which rules apply?
The amended definition applies based on when the lawsuit is commenced, not when the crash occurred. An older accident filed after May 26, 2026 is generally governed by the new rules. Given how much turns on this, timing should be reviewed with an attorney rather than assumed.
Can I still recover if the truck driver claims I caused the crash?
Yes, but your fault percentage now matters more than it once did. Your award reduces in proportion to your share of the blame, and under CPLR § 1411 a plaintiff found mostly at fault in a motor vehicle case cannot recover non-economic damages at all. Because juries now decide fault before hearing the injury evidence, early documentation of the scene carries unusual weight.
I have a concussion but my scans came back clean. Do I have a case?
Possibly, though it is harder than it was. Without the 90/180 route, a mild traumatic brain injury has to qualify as a permanent consequential limitation or a significant limitation of use, which calls for neuropsychological testing and consistent specialist documentation. Reporting cognitive symptoms early and continuing treatment without gaps makes a substantial difference.
How does the $100,000 cap affect my truck accident claim?
For most people, not at all. It applies only to an at-fault injured person in a narrow set of circumstances — uninsured while responsible for insuring the vehicle, impaired and later convicted, or committing a felony and later convicted — and it excludes death cases. It is worth knowing about mainly so it cannot be raised where it does not belong.
Key Takeaways
✅ Eight threshold categories remain — the 90/180-day route is gone
✅ A documented fracture clears the threshold on its own
✅ The new rules apply by filing date, not accident date
✅ Juries now decide fault first, injury second — fault evidence matters more
✅ Soft tissue and clean-scan TBI claims need objective proof to survive
Injured by a Truck in Brooklyn?
The threshold is a gate, not a valuation — clearing it opens the claim, and what happens next depends on the fault record and the coverage behind the vehicle. A Brooklyn truck accident lawyer can build the medical documentation the amended standard now demands and contest the fault allocation before the carrier’s version of events settles into the record. The case review is free, and there is no fee unless you win.
Get Connected With a Brooklyn Truck Accident Lawyer Today
Free case review. No win, no fee. No upfront cost.
Want more NYC injury guides and legal news from PILNY in your Google results?