TL;DR — Quick Summary
A New York slip and fall case turns on one question: did the owner create the hazard, or know (or should have known) about it in time to fix it? New York courts apply that “notice” rule strictly, along with specific doctrines on trivial defects, storms in progress and wet floors on rainy days. Your deadline depends on who owns the property — three years against a private owner, but a 90-day notice of claim against the City, NYCHA or NYC Transit. If you were partly at fault, New York’s pure comparative fault rule reduces your award but does not bar it.
Slip and fall claims look simple from the outside: someone fell, someone owned the property. In New York they are some of the most fiercely defended injury cases there are, because the law requires more than a fall and an injury. This guide explains what a slip and fall attorney in New York will look at first — the rules that decide whether a claim succeeds, who can be held responsible, the deadlines, and what drives the value of a case.
What You Have to Prove
A New York premises claim has four parts:
- A dangerous condition existed — not just an accident, but a hazard such as a broken step, a spill, ice or a raised sidewalk slab.
- The defendant owned, occupied, controlled or made special use of the property.
- The defendant created the condition, or had actual or constructive notice of it.
- The condition caused your fall and your injuries.
Most cases are won or lost on the third element.
The Notice Rule That Decides Most Cases
If the owner or its staff created the hazard — a freshly mopped floor with no sign, a contractor’s hose across a walkway — you do not need to prove notice. Otherwise you must show one of two things:
- Actual notice: the owner knew. Complaint logs, emails to the super, 311 complaints and prior incident reports are the usual proof.
- Constructive notice: the owner should have known. Under the Court of Appeals’ decision in Gordon v American Museum of Natural History (1986), the defect must have been visible and apparent and must have existed long enough before the accident for the owner’s employees to find and fix it.
This is why timing evidence matters so much. A spill that appeared two minutes before your fall usually does not create liability; a dirty, footprinted puddle beside a register that staff walked past for an hour often does. Photographs taken immediately — showing the size, colour, track marks and surroundings of the hazard — are frequently the best notice evidence a case will ever have.
Defences You Will Hear About
“The defect was trivial”
Owners often argue that a crack or height difference was too small to be actionable. New York has no fixed minimum: in Trincere v County of Suffolk (1997) and Hutchinson v Sheridan Hill House Corp. (2015), the Court of Appeals held that size is only one factor, alongside the defect’s shape, location, lighting and whether it was hidden by something else. A half-inch lip at the edge of a dim stair can be actionable; the same lip in the middle of a bright, open plaza may not be.
“It was still snowing”
Under the storm-in-progress doctrine, an owner is not liable for snow or ice that falls during a storm, and gets a reasonable time after it ends to clear it. In New York City, the Administrative Code requires owners to clear the sidewalk within four hours after the snow stops, with overnight hours not counted. Weather records and the timing of your fall decide many winter cases.
“It was raining — water gets tracked in”
New York courts do not require stores and lobbies to cover every floor with mats or mop continuously on a rainy day. A claim is stronger where the water had built up to an unusual level, mats were missing or curled, or a known leak was ignored.
“You should have seen it”
An “open and obvious” hazard does not automatically defeat a claim in New York — it goes to your share of the fault rather than ending the case. See the section on comparative fault below.
Who Is Responsible Depends on Where You Fell
| Location | Usual defendant |
|---|---|
| Store, restaurant, office | The business that occupies the space, and often the building owner. A lease decides who maintained what. |
| Apartment building common areas | The landlord and managing agent; the Multiple Dwelling Law requires them to keep stairs, halls and lighting in good repair. See apartment slip and fall claims in NYC. |
| City sidewalk | Usually the abutting property owner under NYC Admin Code § 7-210; the City for owner-occupied one-to-three family homes, curbs and tree wells. See who is liable for a sidewalk slip and fall in NYC. |
| NYCHA development | The New York City Housing Authority — a public authority with its own notice-of-claim rule. |
| Subway station or bus | NYC Transit (MTA). Station entrances in private buildings can involve the building owner too. |
| Construction area or scaffolding | The contractor that created the condition, plus the owner. Workers injured on site may also have Labor Law claims. |
Whether you slipped or tripped also changes the proof — a trip usually involves a physical defect, a slip usually a transient substance. Our guide to trip and fall vs slip and fall explains the difference.
Deadlines: Three Years or 90 Days
| Defendant | First deadline | Time to sue |
|---|---|---|
| Private owner, store or landlord | None | 3 years |
| City of New York, NYCHA, NYC Transit | Notice of claim within 90 days | Generally 1 year and 90 days |
| State of New York (state property) | Claim or notice of intention in the Court of Claims within 90 days | Within 2 years if a notice of intention was served |
| Port Authority (airports, PATH, bus terminal) | Notice at least 60 days before suing | 1 year |
The City’s 90-day rule comes from General Municipal Law § 50-e. A court can sometimes allow a late notice, but it is discretionary and should never be relied on. For every deadline and the exceptions that pause the clock, see how long you have to file a personal injury claim in New York.
If You Were Partly at Fault
New York uses pure comparative fault for premises cases. Your damages are reduced by your percentage of responsibility, but you can still recover even if you were mostly to blame. If a jury values a case at $200,000 and finds you 30% at fault for looking at your phone, you recover $140,000. Expect the defence to argue that the hazard was obvious, your footwear was wrong or you were distracted; evidence of lighting, sightlines and the hazard’s appearance answers those arguments.
What Drives the Value of a Slip and Fall Case
There is no statutory formula for pain and suffering in New York. Adjusters sometimes use a “multiplier” of medical bills as a starting point, but juries and appellate courts look at the injury itself. The factors that move value most are:
- The injury and treatment: a fracture needing surgery, a torn meniscus or rotator cuff, or a head injury is valued far above a sprain that healed in weeks.
- Permanency: lasting limitation, hardware, or a future surgery recommendation.
- Liability strength: clear notice evidence raises value; a weak notice case lowers it, whatever the injury.
- Lost earnings: documented time off work and any reduced capacity.
- Venue: where the case would be tried, which in New York City usually means the county where the fall happened or where a party lives.
For typical ranges by injury, see average personal injury settlement amounts in New York, or get a rough estimate with our settlement calculator.
Evidence to Secure in the First Week
- Photos and video of the hazard and the area around it, from several distances, before it is cleaned or repaired.
- Names and numbers of witnesses, including employees who came to help.
- The incident report number — ask for a copy, but you do not have to sign a statement.
- A written request to the owner to preserve surveillance footage. Many systems record over themselves within days or weeks.
- The shoes you were wearing, kept as they are.
- Prompt medical records that describe how the fall happened.
Hurt in Brooklyn or the Bronx? See our Brooklyn slip and fall injury lawyer page. If you are ready to choose a lawyer, our guide on how to find a slip and fall attorney nearby covers what to look for.
Frequently Asked Questions
How long do I have to file a slip and fall claim in New York?
Three years against a private owner or business. Against the City of New York, NYCHA or NYC Transit, you must serve a notice of claim within 90 days and generally sue within one year and 90 days.
Do I have to prove the owner knew about the hazard?
Yes, unless the owner created it. You must show actual notice, or constructive notice — that the hazard was visible and apparent and existed long enough for the owner to find and fix it.
Can I sue if the crack or step I tripped on was small?
Possibly. New York has no minimum height. Courts weigh the defect’s size together with its shape, location, lighting and whether it was hidden.
Who is liable if I slip on ice on a New York City sidewalk?
Usually the abutting property owner, who must clear the sidewalk within four hours after snow stops, with overnight hours not counted. Owners are not liable for snow that falls during a storm in progress.
What if I was partly at fault for my fall?
You can still recover. New York’s pure comparative fault rule reduces your damages by your share of fault; being 30% at fault on a $200,000 case leaves $140,000.
How much does a slip and fall attorney in New York cost?
Nothing upfront. The fee is a percentage of the recovery, capped by court rule at one-third of the net or a sliding schedule, and there is no fee if nothing is recovered.
Key Takeaways
✅ Notice — or the owner creating the hazard — decides most cases
✅ No minimum defect size, but storms in progress and rainy-day floors are common defences
✅ City, NYCHA and NYC Transit claims need a notice of claim within 90 days
✅ Partial fault reduces your award but does not bar it
✅ Photos, witnesses and preserved video in the first days are the best evidence
Get a Free Slip and Fall Case Review
We connect people hurt in falls across New York City with experienced premises liability lawyers. The review is free, and the lawyer is paid only if you recover. Fees are explained in our guide to personal injury lawyer fees in New York.
Hurt in a Fall? Pay Nothing Unless You Win
Free case review. Deadlines checked on day one.
